weather: any city he names, not the six in a table (V-421)

The hand-written table understood "какая погода в X" for six values of X.
Ask about Kazan or Tbilisi and the city was dropped silently and answered for
the default location — a correct-sounding answer about the wrong place.

The table is gone. internal/weather already calls Open-Meteo's geocoding
endpoint on every lookup, so the place he named goes straight there and any
place it knows is a place he can ask about. He speaks the prepositional case,
so locationCandidates reverses the two endings that cover most of it: a final
"е" is a nominative "а" or nothing, a final "и" is a soft sign. A wrong
candidate finds no city; it never invents one.

A place the geocoder does not have now reads as "не знаю такого города"
rather than as a provider outage or, worse, as the default city's weather.
ErrLocationUnknown is what carries that apart.

"в" followed by a room or a day word is still the default location. Those
questions are answered by the house sensors and the calendar, not by
Open-Meteo, and they must not be read as a city.
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-04 03:25:42 +04:00
parent d60a51c9e7
commit ea9c746852
6 changed files with 169 additions and 34 deletions
+5
View File
@@ -390,6 +390,11 @@ func (h *reactiveHandler) queryWeather(ctx context.Context, t *queryTurn) (strin
if errors.Is(err, weather.ErrNotConfigured) {
return "погода не настроена.", true
}
if errors.Is(err, weather.ErrLocationUnknown) {
// He named a place and the geocoder does not have it. Saying so beats
// reading out the default city's temperature (Vikunja #421).
return "не знаю такого города — " + loc + ".", true
}
if err != nil {
log.Printf("voice: weather: %v", err)
return "не получилось узнать погоду.", true
+45 -33
View File
@@ -1,10 +1,13 @@
// Package main — weatherq.go holds the weather-query keyword helpers: does
// this utterance ask about weather at all, and which city (if any) did it
// name. Both are plain substring/lookup matching, not NLU — extend this file
// rather than voice.go for anything in that shape.
// this utterance ask about weather at all, and which place (if any) did he
// name. Both are plain keyword matching, not NLU — extend this file rather
// than voice.go for anything in that shape.
package main
import "strings"
import (
"regexp"
"strings"
)
// isWeatherQuery returns true if the utterance is about weather.
func isWeatherQuery(u string) bool {
@@ -19,40 +22,49 @@ func isWeatherQuery(u string) bool {
strings.Contains(lower, "temperature")
}
// weatherCities — the city names an utterance may name explicitly, as
// lowercase substrings mapped to the provider's spelling. This is a
// convenience for "какая погода в Лондоне", NOT a source of default truth:
// nothing here is used unless he actually said it.
var weatherCities = map[string]string{
"москв": "Moscow",
"moscow": "Moscow",
"питер": "Saint Petersburg",
"spb": "Saint Petersburg",
"петербур": "Saint Petersburg",
"лондон": "London",
"london": "London",
"париж": "Paris",
"paris": "Paris",
"берлин": "Berlin",
"berlin": "Berlin",
"нью-йорк": "New York",
"new york": "New York",
// weatherPlace — the place he named, after "в"/"во"/"in". One or two words,
// letters and dashes only, so "в Нижнем Новгороде" and "in New York" both
// come through whole and "в 5 утра" does not.
var weatherPlace = regexp.MustCompile(`(?i)(?:^|\s)(?:в|во|in)\s+([\p{L}-]+(?:\s+[\p{L}-]+)?)`)
// weatherNonPlaces — words that follow "в" in a weather question and are not
// cities. "какая погода в доме" is the smart-home sensor, not Open-Meteo, and
// "тепло в комнате" is the same question about the same room.
var weatherNonPlaces = map[string]bool{
"доме": true, "квартире": true, "комнате": true, "спальне": true,
"гостиной": true, "кухне": true, "гараже": true, "офисе": true,
"выходные": true, "субботу": true, "воскресенье": true, "понедельник": true,
"вторник": true, "среду": true, "четверг": true, "пятницу": true,
"обед": true, "обеде": true, "утро": true, "утром": true, "вечер": true,
"вечером": true, "ночь": true, "ночью": true, "целом": true, "принципе": true,
}
// extractWeatherLocation returns the city he named, or the configured default
// extractWeatherLocation returns the place he named, or the configured default
// when he named none. It returns "" when he named none AND no default is
// configured — the caller must then say it does not know.
//
// It used to return "Moscow" in that case. That is a made-up answer presented
// as fact: reading out Moscow's temperature to someone who is not in Moscow is
// wrong in exactly the way maven must never be wrong. voice.weather
// .default_location is the only source of an unstated location.
// It used to be a hand-written table of six cities in two spellings each
// (Vikunja #421). Anything outside it — Kazan, Tbilisi — was dropped silently
// and answered for the default location, which reads as a correct answer about
// the wrong place. There is a geocoder behind this now: internal/weather
// already calls Open-Meteo's geocoding endpoint for every lookup, so any place
// it knows is a place he can ask about, and the table bought nothing.
//
// A named place that the geocoder cannot resolve is the caller's problem to
// report, not this function's to hide.
//
// It used to return "Moscow" when he named nothing. That is a made-up answer
// presented as fact. voice.weather.default_location is the only source of an
// unstated location.
func extractWeatherLocation(u, defaultLoc string) string {
lower := strings.ToLower(u)
for substr, name := range weatherCities {
if strings.Contains(lower, substr) {
return name
}
m := weatherPlace.FindStringSubmatch(u)
if m == nil {
return defaultLoc
}
return defaultLoc
place := strings.TrimSpace(m[1])
first := strings.ToLower(strings.Fields(place)[0])
if weatherNonPlaces[first] {
return defaultLoc
}
return place
}
+33
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
package main
import "testing"
// TestExtractWeatherLocation — any place he names comes through, not just the
// six that used to be in a table (Vikunja #421).
func TestExtractWeatherLocation(t *testing.T) {
cases := []struct {
utterance string
def string
want string
}{
// The cities the table had, and the ones it silently dropped.
{"какая погода в Москве", "Berlin", "Москве"},
{"какая погода в Казани", "Berlin", "Казани"},
{"погода в Тбилиси?", "Berlin", "Тбилиси"},
{"what's the weather in New York", "Berlin", "New York"},
{"тепло в Нижнем Новгороде?", "Berlin", "Нижнем Новгороде"},
// He named nothing: the configured default, and nothing at all when
// there is no default.
{"какая сегодня погода", "Berlin", "Berlin"},
{"какая сегодня погода", "", ""},
// "в" followed by something that is not a place stays the default —
// the house sensors and the day words answer elsewhere.
{"тепло в комнате?", "Berlin", "Berlin"},
{"какая погода в выходные", "Berlin", "Berlin"},
}
for _, c := range cases {
if got := extractWeatherLocation(c.utterance, c.def); got != c.want {
t.Errorf("extractWeatherLocation(%q, %q) = %q, want %q", c.utterance, c.def, got, c.want)
}
}
}