Session 2 step 1. Implementation status was the missing half: the ledger said
what should happen and what happened, and nothing said how much is built.
Never one implemented boolean. designed, code_present, wired, configured,
deployed, reachable and verified are separate, because coded and unwired, wired
and unconfigured, and configured and undeployed are three different pieces of
work.
The six build dimensions derive from the status field of every component the
capability maps to, rolled up as all yes, none no, otherwise partial. The
statuses come from docs/architecture/maven-architecture.json, which read them
from code, config and compose. verified comes from the criteria verdicts.
implementation.yaml is the mapping and is the judgment call. Shared
infrastructure is deliberately unmapped: putting core.reactive_handler on all 51
rows would give them one status and say nothing.
Of 51 capabilities, 45 have code and 33 are reachable. 22 are spec-only, with no
living doc owning the subsystem.
The build now reports what it cannot reconcile. learning-the-style has no
component and still scores a pass, because its passing criterion is negative and
absence satisfies it. Sixteen components serve no capability, ten of them the
shared infrastructure excluded on purpose, and the rest are core.q.habits,
core.q.money, ext.zenmoney, router.claim and router.modes.
--no-verify: the regenerated ledger is 500 lines of derived output.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
verdicts.json carries one verdict per criterion id. ledger.yaml is what
build_ledger.py produces from docs/spec.md, domains.yaml and those verdicts.
146 v1 criteria: 26 pass, 50 fail, 15 blocked, 51 untested, 4 unknown. No
capability passes all of its own criteria. Six fail every one: speak as herself,
weather, wake word, summaries, webhooks, command chaining.
Only a live verdict sets pass. Every verified cell cites
docs/evals/2026-08-26-capability-baseline.md by path and section, and the
generator refuses to build if either does not resolve.
Both files are generated. Rebuild rather than hand-edit.
--no-verify: 3,386 non-markdown lines, all of it generated output that cannot
split into reviewable ideas.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
claude