V-560 classified the side query correctly and then dropped the request behind
it, saying "Прошлую просьбу отпускаю." The owner rejected that on sight: he
asked about the weather in the middle of setting a reminder, and being told the
reminder was let go reports a loss he did not ask for. It had not been lost —
there was simply nowhere to put it.
There is now. ClarifyStore grew a bounded stack in V-559 and nothing called
Push; this is the caller it was built for. A side query leaves the question
parked exactly as it is, the words are answered as themselves, and the question
comes back on the end of the same reply — one utterance, two acts.
The resumed question is not the first one again. "Когда?" works in the same
breath as "напомни позвонить маме" and does not work after a turn about Rome, so
the deck has a second form per slot that names the request: "На какое время
поставить напоминание?". No attempt is spent, because he answered the side query
and not the parked question, and charging a retry for a turn that was never an
answer is the V-554 shape.
clarifyDropped stays for new_request and cancel, where something really does
die. Two things can now die at once, so TakeExpired reports a count instead of a
bool and the expiry notice has a plural wording — "прошлую просьбу" when two
were lost would be a lie about the number.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
One parked question per dialogue id meant a side query could only destroy
the flow it interrupted. The store now keeps a stack per id, newest last,
with Push, Peek, Pop, Depth and Delete as drop-all. MaxStackDepth is 2:
one flow plus the thing he interrupted it with, because spoken
conversation does not nest deeper, and because every level she keeps is a
level she has to be able to speak when it dies.
Behaviour is unchanged. Put still replaces the top rather than growing the
stack — a re-ask is another question about the same action — and nothing
calls Push yet, so the daemon runs at depth one exactly as before. Get is
Peek under the name the callers already use. An expired top takes the
stack with it and TakeExpired reports it, so no parked action dies without
a word; Push returns the entry the depth bound forced out for the same
reason.
PendingQuestion.IsExpired and CanAsk now answer through PendingAction, so
the TTL and attempt-cap rules have one copy and the widening cannot drift.
The decision, not a behaviour change: ClarifyStore stays in memory, and she
does not announce the loss either.
The TTL and the attempt count measure a pause in one conversation. A restart
is a gap of unknown length, so a restored question is either dead already or
lying about its age, and the request behind it is one he has likely given up
on. Announcing it would mean storing a marker that outlives the thing it
describes, to say one sentence in the rare window where he speaks within 90s
of a restart. His next words route fresh, which is right either way.
Written down in docs/design.md, pinned at both ends by a comment, and held by
a test that builds a second handler over the same store.
MaxAttempts was 1, justified as "not a nag". Wrong reading: "not a nag" is about
interrupting unprompted, and a clarifying question is part of a conversation he
started. Now three, configurable via voice.clarify_max_attempts (default 3).
Three, because after that the likely problem is she misheard the whole request,
not one slot.
Answer used to keep the parked value, so "в три" then "нет, в пять" threw the
five away. Now a value the answer carries wins for the slot she asked about.
Only for the clarify answer — a correction in a fresh turn is followUpMerge.
The eight-field chained assertion in the Answer test is one DeepEqual now, so a
new field in Slots is covered without touching the test.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01CGeSZxh1DCtRxmFVSYVGvJ
PendingQuestion plus ClarifyStore: same shape, locking and expiry as SessionStore. Answer fills only the missing slots and never overwrites a filled one. No wiring yet — TODOs mark the daemon hooks.
Reviewer: MaxAttempts is 1 on purpose (Maven asks once, she is not a nag).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01CGeSZxh1DCtRxmFVSYVGvJ
claude
kami