# Domain assignment for the capability ledger. The one human input to # build_ledger.py; everything else in ledger.yaml is mechanical. # # At most two domains, PRIMARY FIRST. Three independent passes ran under # different lenses (bottom-up from the DoD, from the owner's experience, # from state ownership and effect), then one reconciler re-read the DoD of # every contested row and broke the tie. A row marked (contested) is one the # three passes did not agree on; its note names what broke the tie. # # 35 of 51 were unanimous. Goes to the owner once, before any probe runs. # Unanimous: every criterion interprets an utterance into intent plus source and records which stage decided. route-an-utterance: [deliberation] # Contested; broken by criterion count: two of three DoD lines are parked-turn dialogue lifecycle (cancel by "отмена", survive an interleaved turn and resume), and none is a permission or confirmation, so interaction beats governance for second. (contested) ask-instead-of-guessing: [deliberation, interaction] # Unanimous: every criterion polices what wording reaches the outbound wire. speak-as-herself: [interaction] # Contested; broken by criterion dbeb, which is the privacy ordering rule (owner's sources before anything outside, every time), not an interpretation step, so governance beats deliberation. (contested) answer-from-your-own-data: [memory, governance] # Unanimous: retrieve an external answer, bounded by what may leave the box. answer-from-the-world: [action, governance] # Unanimous: pick the right Kiwix book and retrieve a topically correct article — pure retrieval. read-an-encyclopedia: [action] # Unanimous: call a configured provider, with the follow-up city parked as a clarify rather than guessed. weather: [action, deliberation] # Contested; I overrule the two perception-first votes on the ledger's own weather logic: the DoD is an offloaded vision tool call over content he supplied, with a silent fallback, so it is a tool call first and sensing second. (contested) see-an-image: [action, perception] # Contested; broken by reading the criteria: write, honest confirmation, supersede and Nexus-resolved subject are all fact-store integrity, and none is a permission, privacy or confirmation-binding rule, so governance drops. (contested) facts: [memory] # Contested; broken by criterion count: capture, recall and delete are the store's lifecycle, and "a question is not stored as a statement" is a routing defect already owned by route-an-utterance, so deliberation drops. (contested) notes: [memory] # Unanimous across all three passes: it reads the note and fact store through # the embedder, with the personal boundary deciding what that read may cross # into. Recovered from the three passes' journal: the reconciler dropped this # row from its 51, and build_ledger.py's guard caught the omission. recall: [memory, governance] # Contested; broken by the ledger finding that the evaluator cannot speak: nothing surfaces to him, so initiative cannot hold, and the DoD's checkable conclusions over notes it read are deliberation. (contested) memory-evaluation: [memory, deliberation] # Unanimous: hold a future commitment, fire it at its time, and get it delivered across reaches. reminders: [attention, interaction] # Unanimous: the whole DoD is whether an unprompted item may break in, keyed on presence and severity. interruption-policy: [initiative, perception] # Unanimous: a suppressed nudge candidate must resurface unprompted in a later digest, without acting. digest-of-held-nudges: [initiative, attention] # Unanimous: an unprompted plan inside its window that must find another reach rather than be dropped. morning-routine: [initiative, interaction] # Unanimous: propose from observed repeated behaviour and store the decline. routine-proposals: [initiative, memory] # Unanimous: open items ordered by deadline and urgency over a stored work list. tasks: [attention, memory] # Unanimous: fetch configured feeds and find the matching item on request, explicitly never unprompted. rss-and-news: [action] # Unanimous: outbound delivery with an outbox row and continuous inbound reading — a reach. telegram: [interaction] # Unanimous: a push reach whose criteria are its credential and not looping when refused. ntfy: [interaction] # Unanimous: a live speech reach, capped at L0 and bound to loopback. voice: [interaction, governance] # Unanimous: a page per capability with step-up standing in front of a destructive write. web-ui: [interaction, governance] # Unanimous: inbound ingests desktop events as low-confidence facts; the outbound half is an undecided fourth reach. desk-notifications: [perception, interaction] # Contested; broken by the DoD being accuracy-enough-to-route plus a silent fallback arm on the voice surface, with nothing about context, so interaction leads and perception stays second. (contested) speech-to-text: [interaction, perception] # Unanimous: the reply rendered as Russian speech with times and numbers expanded for the ear. text-to-speech: [interaction] # Contested; broken by criterion 10ca being the detection itself ("Мэйвен" wakes her, a near-miss does not) — the session it opens belongs to voice, so perception leads. (contested) wake-word: [perception, interaction] # Contested; broken by the DoD being a microphone capture client existing at all — sensing that must exist before any surface — so perception leads over the reach it feeds. (contested) hearing: [perception, interaction] # Contested (order only); broken by criterion 3110 being the recognition itself, with the act-path gate the second criterion it feeds, so perception leads. (contested) speaker-recognition: [perception, governance] # Unanimous: free text resolves to a canonical entity or she asks, and that resolution precedes any mutating call. nexus: [deliberation, governance] # Unanimous: the source of items needing attention, bound by lifecycle words and the no-auto-act rule. praxis: [attention, governance] # Unanimous: the only path that changes the world, bound by a confirmation LLM output cannot supply. hexis: [action, governance] # Unanimous: control a device through Hexis on a Nexus-resolved entity, never by free text. smart-home: [action, governance] # Contested; broken by what the rate-limit criterion actually is — a politeness bound in config, not an authorization gate — so governance drops and action stands alone. (contested) network-scans: [action] # Unanimous: connect and disconnect a paired radio device through the act path. bluetooth-control: [action] # Unanimous: external tools callable through the act path with the allowlist as the only door. mcps: [action, governance] # Unanimous: compose services on the current build and a lossless restart — infrastructure, filed under Operations. the-deployed-stack: [operations] # Contested; broken by all three criteria being secrecy mechanisms (at-rest encryption, key held only by mavend, passwords from files), which is governance's privacy clause carried by infrastructure. (contested) encrypted-database: [operations, governance] # Unanimous: no privileged gate fail-open and step-up per-request — authorization, filed under Operations. passkey-and-step-up: [governance, operations] # Unanimous: which gguf may load and whether the swap survives a restart. model-swap: [operations] # Unanimous: updating the deployment from inside it and rolling back a failure. self-update: [operations] # Unanimous: the build and analyzer gate itself, no agent behaviour in it. tests-and-analyzers: [operations] # Unanimous: a mail workflow whose open criteria are candidates staying candidates and no content leaving the box. email-triage: [action, governance] # Contested; broken by criteria 4047 and 5f7c both refusing to proceed on an under-determined request (ask for the slot, name the conflict), which is deliberation, not proactive attention. (contested) calendar-management: [action, deliberation] # Contested; broken by criterion count: two of four are constraints (robots and politeness, only the URL and utterance leave) against one for the watch, so governance takes second — the watch does pull at initiative. (contested) web-crawling: [action, governance] # Unanimous: pull a named source and condense it, refusing a summary that would invent content. summaries: [action, governance] # Contested; broken by criterion 5134 naming authentication for both directions explicitly, which outweighs the inbound half's perception flavour. (contested) webhooks: [interaction, governance] # Unanimous: a user-set schedule that runs acts under the same confirmation rules as a spoken act. cron-jobs: [action, governance] # Unanimous: a correction stored as a readable, deletable outcome whose only effect is later phrasing. learning-the-style: [memory, interaction] # Unanimous: stored outcomes from dismissals and repairs that change the next decision. learning-from-mistakes: [memory, deliberation] # Contested; broken by criterion 77b5 stating that a chain containing an act confirms each act separately, an explicit confirmation rule that outranks the generic "performs both" pull toward action. (contested) command-chaining: [deliberation, governance]