Compare commits

..

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
claude dc266056d1 docs: the shape and the rules for offloading model work (V-483)
483 is an umbrella and its children are the work, so what it owes them is
the shape they must all obey. docs/offload.md records it: the degradation
rule and where its line falls, admission control rather than a GPU
arbiter, the embedder staying on homesrv because it backs the classifier,
and the inventory of what runs a model on the box today.

CLAUDE.md gets a pointer, because an agent about to add a model caller or
touch a daemon seam needs to know this before it starts, not after.
2026-08-02 15:08:35 +02:00
kami 1c786b7156 Merge pull request 'Docs: refresh the QA plan against the live task list' (#92) from task/483-design-offload-ml-to-the-workstation-kee into master
Reviewed-on: #92
2026-08-02 15:08:16 +02:00
2 changed files with 122 additions and 0 deletions
+8
View File
@@ -28,6 +28,14 @@ model is a one-line change to `phraser.model_path` in `deploy/mavend.json`.
See `docs/rearchitecture.md` for the target architecture, `docs/design.md` for the folded design spec, and
`AGENTS.md` for local-preview + model-download recipes.
**Model work is moving to the workstation** (owner's call, 2026-08-02). homesrv cannot grow a
GPU and the workstation has 16GB of VRAM. So the resident model, STT and TTS become preferred
remotes with a floor on homesrv. The workstation is never assumed up. Fall back silently when
it would only do the job better. Name the gap when the 1.7B cannot do it at all. The embedder
stays on homesrv permanently, because it backs that floor. Read `docs/offload.md` before
touching a daemon seam or adding a model caller. Vikunja #483 is the umbrella, #484 to #487
are the work.
## Build & test
CGO daemons (`mavend`, `mavsttd`, `mavttsd`, `mavenclient`) need the vendored toolchain
+114
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,114 @@
# Offloading model work to the workstation
*Last verified: 2026-08-02 @ 5c05163. Living doc: correct it in place, do not append.*
Owner's call, 2026-08-02. Vikunja #483 is the umbrella. Tasks #484 to #487 are the
work, and this file holds the shape and the rules all four must obey.
## The goal
homesrv cannot grow a GPU. The workstation has 16GB of VRAM. Move the model work
to the workstation and leave homesrv running the logic that must be always-on,
deterministic and cheap.
## Why this is tractable
The split already exists structurally. `mavsttd` and `mavttsd` are separate
daemons that core reaches over a socket, not linked libraries. Moving them off-box
is a transport change, not a redesign.
The microphone is at the workstation, because that is where the owner sits and
homesrv is headless. So speech-to-text and the wake word are already on the
workstation side by construction. Audio never has to cross the LAN. Only the core
turn does.
## The constraint that shapes everything
The workstation's GPU is often busy: CPT runs, experiments, Correx, the manga-recap
pipeline. It also sleeps. homesrv does not.
So an offloaded model is never *the* model. It is the preferred one, with a floor
on homesrv. That is the shape the cascade already has, where a router error falls
through to the classifier.
## The degradation rule
Two cases, and the line between them is sharp.
**Fall back silently** when the workstation model would only do the job *better*:
routing, phrasing, a nudge. Falling back costs nothing that exists today, because
the resident Qwen3-1.7B is today's production quality. The owner should not be told
that his reply was phrased by the smaller model.
**Name the gap** when the resident model cannot do the job *at all*. A world
question that a 1.7B answers by inventing is the case. A wrong answer is worse
than "не могу сейчас". This is the rule CLAUDE.md already states for a sibling
service being down.
Nothing in between. A turn never breaks on the workstation being asleep.
## Admission control, not a scheduler
There is no GPU arbiter. That is a service with its own failure modes, and nothing
here needs work *distributed*. It needs admission control. The workstation
advertises free VRAM over a health endpoint, and Maven treats it as one more query
source that claims a turn or passes. llama-server also refuses to load when VRAM is
short, so the failure is detectable without cooperation from the owner's other
jobs.
The caller must be able to ask "is this peer usable right now" without a turn
hanging on a timeout. A dead remote is a normal state, not an error state.
## What stays on homesrv, permanently
The **embedder** (multilingual-e5-small, ONNX, CPU). It backs the classifier, which
must answer while the GPU is saturated. It is also cheap enough on CPU that moving
it buys nothing. Four callers:
| Caller | What for |
|---|---|
| `internal/router/classifier.go` | the routing floor |
| `cmd/mavend/actions_query.go` (`queryEmbed`) | memory recall |
| `cmd/mavend/feeds.go` | ingest embedding for every RSS item |
| `internal/crawl/watch.go` | ingest embedding for every crawled page |
`internal/speaker` becomes a fifth once it lands.
## Inventory: what runs a model on homesrv today
The **resident model** is one llama-server with seven callers:
| Caller | What for |
|---|---|
| `cmd/mavend/voicewire.go` | routing |
| `cmd/mavend/replier_llm.go` | replies |
| `cmd/mavend/tick.go` | digestion worker: `PhraseNudge`, `PhraseReminder` |
| `cmd/mavend/capture.go` | capture summarisation (unreachable, see #480) |
| `cmd/mavend/mail.go` | mail extraction (off, no IMAP) |
| `cmd/mavend/kiwixwire.go` | answering from a Kiwix, search or crawl passage |
| `memoryeval.go`, `modelswap.go` | admin and evals |
Then the embedder above, **whisper.cpp** in `mavsttd`, and **piper** in `mavttsd`.
`mavwaked` uses no model at all: an energy-threshold VAD over 30ms frames.
## Order
1. **Transport** (#484). Nothing else is possible until a seam can cross a host.
`internal/netaddr` landed in PR #92. A seam address now carries its own scheme,
and a scheme-less one is still unix. A tcp seam requires a shared token, because
the filesystem permission that authenticated the unix socket is gone.
2. **The resident model** (#485). Biggest quality delta. A 16GB card runs a 7-14B,
which fixes what the 1.7B gets wrong: world knowledge, and the persona the CPT
targets. The degradation path is already written and measured, since the
classifier scores 68.8% full accuracy at p50 16.6µs on its own.
3. **Speech-to-text and text-to-speech** (#486). They gain a real margin, but on
quality alone, and both already work.
4. **The wake word** (#487). Independent of all of the above.
## Assumptions
- The LAN is trusted enough that wireguard is supported but not required (owner's
call). What crosses the wire is still his utterances. That is why the tcp seam
carries its own token instead of assuming a network boundary.
- The workstation is not expected to be up. Every child task must still serve a
turn while it is down.